Comic book fans don’t seem to be the most adabtable group of people in the world. Whenever you hear about a comic book movie slightly altering something from the comics, a super hero getting a new costume, or Loki becoming a girl, you’re sure to find a plethora of message boards fueled by nerd rage. It can be quite amusing to see people get so upset that they threaten to burn your house down over some minor changes to fictional characters. That kind of behavior just seems absurd. The truth of the matter is that comic books have actually been grooming their readers to this kind of thought, simply through the fact that most changes that deviate from the original facets of a character are absolutely terrible.
In retrospect, giving Captain America a DD bust was a mistake.
This doesn’t necessarily mean that the stories themselves are terrible, just the results of them. Comic book companies have a habit of creating “what-If” types of storylines featuring alternate dimensions and stuff where different circumstances put well known heroes in odd situations. Marvel had several titles that actually went by the name of What-If, asking questions such as what if Spider-Man kept the power cosmic? All of these stories ended the same way, in disaster. What if Iron Man was a traitor? Then everybody dies. What if Thunderbolt Ross became the Hulk instead of Bruce Banner? Then everybody dies. What if the Invisible Girl married Namor? Then everybody lives happily ever after. No, not really, everybody dies. This kind of thing holds true for almost every alternate universe type of story told in mainstream comics, and usually with the emphasis that the main story line universe (Earth 616 in Marvel comics) is the only one where things are working out okay and the world isn’t about to end. At least not for real.
This holds true with DC titles as well. Their Elseworlds story lines kind of do the same thing as Marvel’s What-If. In one world, Batman is an actual vampire. In another, Superman is a communist. This works out about as well as can be expected. Even the recent DC story line Flashpoint, which was a terrific read, focused on minor changes leading to absolute disaster. We as comic readers have been conditioned to believe that any change to the main continuity of our stories will inevitably lead to disaster. This in itself is not a bad thing, as disasters can be exciting and fun to read about. What makes these disasters unpalatable for us is that they always seem to lead to the end of the story. What-If stories were pretty much always just one issue self contained tales. They didn’t leave room for sequels, so we just read the story, saw our favorite heroes die, and then it was over. These type of stories have made us cautious about any changes made to our favorite heroes, as we don’t want to see their stories come to an end. This kind of paranoia comes up when an artist decides to foolishly wreck the delicate balance of the universe by changing Spider-Man’s costume design, a change which will surely bring about the end of the Marvel universe as we know it.
In our defense, I’m pretty sure the Scarlet Spider/Clone Saga did almost kill the Marvel universe.
















