Thought that Cyclops, Beast and Co. were the original X-Men? Think again. Marvel has unveiled their latest five issue series called “The First X-Men”. It tells the early story of the mutant race, with characters like Wolverine and Magneto battling against an oppressive society.
Another X-Team, just what we needed.
First of all, calling this team “The First X-Men” doesn’t make much sense. I don’t need to tell you that the X-Men are Xavier’s creation, and the team didn’t exist before he created it. More importantly, the X-Men aren’t just a stand in for any mutant get-together. They are the followers of Xavier’s dream. That’s what separates an X-Man from something like Magneto’s Brotherhood. The only reason to use the X-Men in the title is to clearly brand this as part of the franchise. As a result it feels derivative and lazy, rather than something fresh and new.
This is a similar problem shared with the series “Avengers 1959”. Yeah, the idea of an old school Nick Fury black ops squad is cool. Very cool in fact. It just has nothing to do with the Avengers legacy. The Avengers were formed when the founding members (Thor, Iron Man, etc) came together to fight a foe no one hero could oppose alone. Since this earlier group had no impact on that event, they just have nothing to do with the Avengers legacy. Just because you say a team is the Avengers or the X-Men doesn’t actually make it true. There are some cases where you can stretch or subvert a title (Dark Avengers is a good example), but it usually doesn’t serve any story purpose.
We also have the issue of making Wolverine the be-all-end-all of the mutant race. Now, Wolverine is awesome, and has proven himself to be one of the most interesting characters in comics. His story also illustrates how governments treated mutants as weapon and experiments, bringing in a rich layer to the mythology of the race. But when you start saying that Wolverine was there since the beginning and has served every function possible, the story of the X-Men starts feeling like the story of Wolverine. Wolverine should be important, but he isn’t the main character of the mutant race. If anyone could claim that title, it would be held by Professor X and Magneto.
Or possibly Skin, the beloved mutant with 6 feet of extra skin.
I will say that the core concept of the team is a good one. There would certainly have been some kind of mutant activity before Xavier, and I even like the idea of Magneto being involved. I just don’t like the way it’s packaged and the inevitable slew of continuity issues. This book does have potential, but has somewhat of an uphill battle ahead of it.





















