After a four year wait, we’re here. The Avengers hit theaters last night and, spoiler alert, it was awesome. It’s big, has great action, fully developed characters, and might just be the funniest movie I’ve ever seen. There are hundreds of reviews out there, so I figured I’d offer some insights from the mind a comic book movie fanatic. Let’s break it down.
Characters

They are awesome.
Captain America- Chris Evans did solid work the first time around, but this time the character really benefits from his costars. The straight laced, old fashioned Captain America feels much more fleshed out when surrounded by such madness. It was incredibly satisfying to see him start to take on a leadership role towards the end, which is something I thought would be left out. The “Man Out of Time” element wasn’t overdone, more focusing on his efforts to bond with the team. This will give Cap’s sequel plenty of room to explore that theme in more depth. We also see Whedon take a little bit more advantage of Cap’s physical abilities, making his powers feel much closer to their comic book levels.
Iron Man- Robert Downey Jr. is still in top form. His banter is better than ever, and Stark shells out a steady string of one liners. What else needs to be said? He’s probably the most complex character on the team
Thor- Hemsworth was a ton of fun in to watch Thor, but this time it’s a more tempered performance. Our beloved thunder god isn’t quite such a dick this time around, and we miss out on some of those spectacular from the solo film like smashing a coffee mug. Luckily, Hemsworth looks a lot more natural on screen, and handles the more mature Thor quite well. The result? The noble warrior straight from the comics.
Hulk- The hero people can’t stop talking about, Ruffalo might have stolen the show. Easily the best Bruce Banner on film, he’s full of nervous energy but somehow feels like he’s keeping his composure. And of course, when “the other guy” is unleashed, he has some of the best moments in the whole movie. By making him part of an ensemble rather than the solo protagonist, they really let the Hulk be a monster. Considering this time the Hulk shares Banner’s likeness, the result is a winner.
SHIELD- I’ll lump all them into one category. Hawkeye doesn’t get a lot of time to shine, sadly. Renner has fun with it, but hopefully in future installments his character can be fleshed out. Until then, agent Barton remains a bit of a mystery, a casual mix of the Ultimates and classic versions of the character. Black Widow on the other hand, was given a lot more focus and plenty of special moments, but ScarJo doesn’t really do it for me. The whole “dark past” angle never interested me, and not much else about her stands out. Samuel L. Jackson finally gets some stuff to do as Nick Fury, and even though the character has some Machiavellian tricks they make him far more sympathetic than the Ultimates version. That works for me, since if we don’t believe Fury is a good man then it casts doubt on the entire Avenger Initiative.
A special shout out goes to Agent Coulson. He has one of the most memorable scenes in the movie, and one that really fits the function of the character as the connective tissue of the Marvel U.
Loki- Our villain, this Loki is far more feral and wild. Although he claims that freedom is a lie and that subjugation is humanity’s preferred state, clearly these are hollow words to him. The invasion is little more than a big temper tantrum, a way of expressing his anger and pain. This is the evil Loki we know from the comics, but one that’s not far removed from the last time we saw him. Even though we’ve seen him as a villain twice, there is still plenty more that can be done with the character in Thor 2.
As for his army? Basically Whedon chose the Chitauri as a generic alien race, a blunt tool. They’re pretty much a new creation, loosely based on Marvel’s Skrull-like aliens in the Ultimate Avengers series. This is fine by me. The aliens aren’t important. I care about the team.

Hmm, an alien. Yawn.
The Movie

One of the least action packed moments in the movie.
The Action- This is easily the most action packed marvel movie. By far. The entire third act is an epic attack on New York, and it’s pretty spectacular. The fighting is briskly paced, not overly fast and jarring like a Bourne movie but not burdened by never ending slo-mo.
The Story- In some ways the weak spot of the movie. Sort of. The plot is rather basic, and we don’t see too many twists and turns. Then again, this isn’t a horrible thing. The basic set up is so tricky that it benefits from a simple, epic scope. The story gives the characters plenty of room to breathe as Whedon’s script explores what makes each of them tick. While the overall structure is basic, this doesn’t make it any less of a rollercoaster.
Final Thoughts- Yep, the Avengers is a blast. If at times it feels long, it more than makes up for it with witty dialogue, great characterization and huge action set pieces. Much like how the only word to describe The Dark Knight was “intense”, the only word for the Avengers is “awesome”. Still, I do have to say that this is not a truly great film. Yes, it’s extremely entertaining, but didn’t walk away feeling like there was a great meaning or emotional journey. Certain scenes are emotional, but at time it feels like maybe things go too fast or without enough gravitas to truly sink in (with one very notable exception). This is a big directorial step for Whedon, and if the inevitable sequel can gain some more dramatic tension and deeper meaning, then we will have a truly perfect superhero movie. Until then, go enjoy the wonderful spectacle that is The Avengers.